Old Fitzgerald is one of the most recognized names in American bourbon history. Known for its rich flavor, iconic decanters, and historical relevance, it holds lasting value among collectors. The line continues to gain attention, especially from those looking to sell older expressions.
Background and History of Old Fitzgerald
Old Fitzgerald was first introduced in the late 1800s by John E. Fitzgerald, a whiskey salesman with a talent for picking fine barrels. The brand gained fame for being one of the few bourbons to be distilled using a wheated mash bill—a choice that set it apart from many other Kentucky bourbons of the time.
In the mid-20th century, the brand was acquired by Stitzel-Weller, one of the most influential distilleries in bourbon history. Under the guidance of Julian “Pappy” Van Winkle Sr., Old Fitzgerald became a staple of quality, especially during an era when many distilleries prioritized mass production.
Today, Old Fitzgerald is produced by Heaven Hill, which acquired the brand in the 1990s. The name has remained relevant, particularly among those who value historic labels and pre-fire bottlings.
What Makes Old Fitzgerald Distinct
One key feature of Old Fitzgerald is its wheated mash bill, which replaces rye with wheat. This creates a smoother, softer bourbon with sweet, rounded notes. Compared to traditional rye-based bourbons, wheated bourbons age differently and offer a different flavor profile, making them appealing for both casual drinkers and collectors.
In addition to the mash bill, Old Fitzgerald is known for its Bottled-in-Bond expressions. These follow strict federal regulations: distilled in one season by one distiller, aged at least four years, and bottled at 100 proof. Bottled-in-Bond bourbons are especially appealing to those interested in historical consistency and production standards.
The Decanter Series, launched in the 1950s and extending through the 1990s, features collectible glass containers that add both aesthetic and monetary value. These decanters are often sought after not just for the bourbon, but for the design and era they represent.
Popular Bottles and Series
Several Old Fitzgerald bottles stand out for collectors and sellers alike:
1. Old Fitzgerald Bottled-in-Bond Decanter Series: Produced in the mid-20th century, these bottles are collectible due to their glass decanters, aging, and quality of liquid.
2. Pre-1992 Stitzel-Weller Bottles: Highly valuable, especially those bottled before Heaven Hill took over production.
3. Old Fitzgerald Prime and 1849 Expressions: Popular during the 1980s and 1990s and often stored in home collections.
4. Recent Bottled-in-Bond Series (Heaven Hill): While more modern, these still hold interest due to their consistent labeling and quality control.
Age statements, distillery markings, and fill levels are important when determining which of these bottles are most desirable in the secondary market.
Factors That Help Determine Value
Several key details help determine the value of commercial bourbon bottles like Old Fitzgerald:
1. Age and Distillery of Origin: Bottles from the Stitzel-Weller era (pre-1992) tend to be the most valuable. Later bottles, especially those with clear bottling dates, can also be worth consideration.
2. Bottle Condition: Labels must be intact and legible. The fill level and seal condition also affect resale value.
3. Decanter Design: Unique or limited-edition glass decanters may increase collector interest.
4. Proof and Statement: Bottled-in-Bond designations and visible age statements can positively influence pricing.
5. Market Demand: While older expressions are in short supply, the current interest in wheated bourbons keeps demand for Old Fitzgerald steady.
We analyze these factors thoroughly during the valuation process.
Why Sell to Scotch Buyers
At Scotch Buyers, we focus exclusively on purchasing bottles from private collectors. We do not sell or broker bottles. This ensures our process is clean, confidential, and focused only on fair and accurate valuations.
We understand the historical significance and market value of rare bourbons like Old Fitzgerald. Whether it’s a single decanter or an entire collection, our team carefully reviews the specifics of each bottle. Because we are experienced with Stitzel-Weller, Heaven Hill, and other related producers, you can expect informed appraisals.
Our goal is to offer a professional, no-pressure process that allows you to receive a fair market offer. We only buy from individuals—not distributors or retail shops—ensuring that every transaction is personal and secure.
How to Sell Your Bottle to Us
The selling process with Scotch Buyers is straightforward and transparent:
1. Submit Bottle Information
Use our online form to share details about your bottle. Include photos, fill level, label condition, and any visible dates or markings.
2. Receive a Valuation
We review the details and provide an honest, market-based valuation. This is based on recent private sales, auction data, and collector interest.
3. Ship or Arrange Pickup
Once the offer is accepted, you can ship the bottle securely or we can help coordinate a pickup depending on location and bottle value.
4. Get Paid
After receiving and inspecting the bottle, we process payment quickly through your preferred secure method.
We aim to make each transaction efficient while treating your bottle with the respect it deserves.
Let Us Value Your Old Fitzgerald Collection
Old Fitzgerald holds a respected place in bourbon history. From its wheated mash bill to its collectible decanters and Bottled-in-Bond labeling, it continues to draw attention from collectors and sellers alike. If you are looking to sell your bottle of Old Fitzgerald, whether from the Stitzel-Weller era or more recent releases, Scotch Buyers offers a simple and informed process.
Our experience with private collections, clear valuation methods, and exclusive buying focus make us a reliable option for those wanting to sell rare and vintage bottles. Let us help you understand the true worth of your bottle—and offer a fair price in return.
Thank you!